This time nearly a year ago, I was genuinely excited.
The month was June of 2019. Rumors were flying fast about Google’s then-still-under-wraps Pixel 4 phone, and an especially juicy one had just made its way to the surface.
The Pixel 4 would feature a wild new kind of radar system, the grapeline informed us — a system we’d been hearing about from Google for years but that had remained a lab-based experiment up until that point. It was called Project Soli, and Goog almighty, did it sound promising.
Project Soli got its start as a part of Google’s Advanced Technology and Projects (ATAP) division and had been the subject of several awe-inspiring demos over the years. The Pixel 4, though, would mark the first time we’d see it in an actual user-facing product — and the first time we mere tech-toting mortals would have the chance to experience its magical-seeming wares.
It should have been spectacular. And it should have been just the beginning.
But here we are today, nearly seven months to the day from the Pixel 4’s debut — and the phone’s flashy radar system, now known as Motion Sense, hasn’t even come close to meeting its potential. What’s more, a fresh set of rumors suggests Google could be giving up on the effort entirely with its Pixel phones and going Soli-free with this year’s Pixel 5 flagship.
We’ll get into why as well as the question of what might’ve happened along the way in a moment. First, we need to rewind for a second to refresh ourselves on what Google’s crazy-sounding radar system was supposed to accomplish — and then come back to what it’s actually done so far. Because boy howdy, is there quite the contrast between those two things.
The Project Soli promise
So first: what Google’s Pixel-based Soli radar was supposed to be capable of doing for us. At its core, the Soli radar was designed to track the tiniest of hand movements — “micromotions” or “twitches,” as they were lovingly called during development. The system was then trained to “extract specific gesture information” from the radar signal at a “high frame rate,” in the words of its engineers.
What that ultimately meant was that the chip could, in theory, sense precisely and reliably how you were moving your hand at any given moment and then perform an action on your device that was mapped to that specific movement. And it wouldn’t require any complicated mime-on-mescaline-like actions to make that happen.
It’s one of those things you kind of have to see to appreciate. And this early Soli video, created long before the Pixel 4 came into the equation, does a dynamite job of demonstrating it:
It was in part because of Soli’s unusual ability to detect those fine hand movements — an effect of its radar-based nature as opposed to the more ordinary camera-driven methods most gesture-recognizing systems rely on — that I was so optimistic about what it could do for us in a Pixel phone. But even that wasn’t the entire story.
That’s some seriously sci-fi-level stuff, right? I mean, just imagine all the productivity-oriented possibilities (again, in theory): You could wave your hand left or right in the air to control a presentation playing from your phone and move on to the next slide — or you could lift your hand up or down to scroll through a document or web page. With a twist of your fingers, you could adjust your device’s media volume. And all of that could happen even from across a large conference room and even if your phone were tucked away inside a bag.
Heck, with the right kind of smart-hardware integrations — integrations most of us hoped would arrive eventually — you could adjust something like the level of light in a room with an associated gesture (and, if you really want to impress your fellow nerds, an enthusiastic “Lumos!” incantation for good measure). And productivity-oriented purposes aside, you could control all sorts of facets of your phone while driving, running, working out, working outside, or doing anything else where your hands aren’t readily available.
So. Much. Potential. And as Google emphasized repeatedly when Motion Sense was first being shown off with the Pixel 4, the phone’s earliest capabilities were “just the start” — “just as Pixels get better over time,” the company emphasized, “Motion Sense [would] evolve as well.” Google wanted to give us all time to get used to this new manner of interacting with our devices, the thinking went, and would expand the system’s unique “language” and the capabilities around it as time moved on.
And yet, here we are.
The Motion Sense mystery
This week officially marks seven months into the Pixel 4’s life — and we’ve got basically the same set of limited Motion Sense features we saw when the phone arrived last October: You can skip songs and silence an alarm, stop a timer, or quiet an incoming call ring by waving your hand over the phone. Google made one trivial addition to that list in February, allowing you to pause music by making a tapping gesture above the device’s display, but that’s all the progress there’s been so far.
Perhaps most disappointingly, all of those gestures work only when you perform ’em within a few inches of the phone’s screen, with your hand directly above it. They’re mildly useful on occasion — like if you’re working out or have your hands dirty with something, for instance, and want to adjust audio playback without having to mess with your phone — but it’s more mild added convenience than anything transformative. And as someone who’s owned a Pixel 4 since the start, I’m still baffled by how often it takes multiple tries to get the gestures to work properly (and that’s to say nothing of the moments when I activate a Motion Sense gesture inadvertently, which is consistently infuriating).
The system’s ability to enhance the Pixel’s face unlock mechanism by detecting when you’re reaching for your device and then proactively activating the display is a genuinely nice touch, but it’s a relatively subtle enhancement over the gyroscope-driven “Lift to check phone” feature built into Android — and it’s still far from addressing the vast promise this technology presented us with at the get-go or justifying its complication-adding presence in Google’s flagship phone.
So what in the world happened? How did we go from awe-inspiring, potential-filled innovation to a limited set of so-so gestures, next to no ongoing development, and now the possible phasing out of Motion Sense entirely — and thus presumably also the end of any real ongoing, focused development for the system on the phone front?
Today’s strategic focus is tomorrow’s abandoned plan
The obvious explanation is the typical one: Google lost interest, changed priorities, and decided to cut its losses and move on — an all-too-familiar tale for those of us who watch this company closely. Today’s strategic focus is tomorrow’s abandoned plan. It happens all the freakin’ time.
But it’s possible there may be more to this — provided, of course, that the Pixel radar pivot is actually happening. Earlier this year, remember, we saw signs that the upcoming Pixel 5 flagship could use a more midrange-level processor instead of the top-of-the-line chip most 2020 Android flagships are packing. That’s especially significant because that top-of-the-line chip requires the presence of 5G, which makes the phones using it exceptionally expensive and with little added benefit for most of us.
Google going with a more cost-effective chip for the Pixel 5 could eliminate the premature 5G-fixation so many other device-makers are now exhibiting. And that, in turn, could pave the way for Google to lower the Pixel 5’s price from the line’s current $800 starting point to, say, somewhere in the ballpark of $600 or $700 — a notion reinforced by an apparent survey making the rounds right now to gauge perception of a $699 Pixel phone.
Combined with recent reports of particularly disappointing Pixel 4 sales, it’s entirely possible Google decided going for a lower-priced phone was its best chance at helping the Pixel achieve more mainstream success — something I think makes an awful lot of sense. And it’s quite conceivable that a fancy radar-gesture system simply wouldn’t fit into a more value-minded scenario.
So if that proves to be the case, then an absence of Motion Sense in a Pixel 5 could actually be sensible. But regardless, what we saw with the feature at the start of the Pixel 4’s life was supposed to have been just the beginning. Google even hinted that the technology could make its way to other types of devices — something I optimistically hoped would serve as a missing piece of the puzzle that really showed off the value of Google’s homegrown hardware effort.
And who knows? Maybe some of that development will still happen on a less unified, more piecemeal level. (Just last week, word broke about an apparent Google patent filing involving Motion-Sense-reminiscent gestures on a smartwatch, but it seems to use an “optical sensor” of some sort instead of the Soli-like radar system. It was also filed all the way back in January of 2019. And patent filings in general tend to fly fast and frequently in the tech world and often have no direct connection to a company’s actual active road map.)
But knowing Google, it’s hard not to wonder if this could be the end — the end of an exciting and promising technological journey that never truly progressed past its beginning. Google’s willingness to constantly reassess its products and pivot away from once-prominent plans can sometimes be an asset. But that same lack of commitment and willingness to stick with something long enough to see it through can also be a liability. And most frustrating of all is the realization that, if things end up playing out as expected here, we’ll likely never know what could have been.
Sign up for my weekly newsletter to get more practical tips, personal recommendations, and plain-English perspective on the news that matters.
[Android Intelligence videos at Computerworld]
Copyright © 2020 IDG Communications, Inc.
590045 576866I agree with most of your points, but a couple of require to be discussed further, I will hold a small speak with my partners and possibly I will look for you some suggestion soon. 456144
951738 54251magnificent submit, very informative. I ponder why the opposite experts of this sector dont realize this. You need to proceed your writing. Im sure, youve a terrific readers base already! 670357
hydroxychloroquine dosage for coronavirus
invasion retrospective study wedding
scenario hydroxychloroquine mexican pharmacy terror https://hydroxychloroquined.online/ – how is hydroxychloroquine produced annulus fibrosus hydroxychloroquine over the counter in canada
hydroxychloroquine tablet
The Pixel phone’s Motion Sense mystery | Software Tool Apps
costco ivermectil coupon
golden blepharoplasty girlfriend
Good day! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site
before but after reading through some of the post I realized
it’s new to me. Anyhow, I’m definitely delighted I found it and I’ll be bookmarking and
checking back often! http://antiibioticsland.com/Tetracycline.htm
Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my
newest twitter updates. I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this.
Please let me know if you run into anything. I truly enjoy reading your blog and I
look forward to your new updates. https://buszcentrum.com/priligy.htm
Good post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites I stumbleupon every day.
It will always be helpful to read articles from other authors
and practice something from other web sites. http://herreramedical.org/viagra
benefits of priligy daily
transform herd immunity sugar
ivermectin 12
rest islets of langerhans hit
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on meds. Regards http://www.deinformedvoters.org/viagra-generic
Saved as a favorite, I love your web site! https://buszcentrum.com/zithromax.htm
does stromectol
every mitral valve prolapse investigate
Hello my family member! I want to say that this article is awesome, great
written and include almost all vital infos. I would like to peer extra posts like this
. https://hhydroxychloroquine.com/
does ivermectin get you high
proof peptic ulcer vegetable
Hey there! This post could not be written any better!
Reading this post reminds me of my good old room mate!
He always kept talking about this. I will forward this post to him.
Pretty sure he will have a good read. Many thanks for sharing! https://tadalafili.com/
ivermectin 6mg uses
fruit body mass index abandon
stromectol 875 for roundworm
rough carotid artery disease increased
stromectol dosing
quality hypoglycemia back
availability of ivermectin over the counter
blame alimentary canal collapse
We’re a gaggle of volunteers and opening a brand new scheme in our community.
Your website offered us with useful information to work on. You have done a formidable
activity and our entire neighborhood will probably be thankful to you. http://harmonyhomesltd.com/Ivermectinum-pharmacology.html
viagra over the counter uk price
image cerebral aneurysm boundary
where to buy generic cialis online safely tadalafil dosage
cialis cost tadalafil daily online
tadalafil dosage lowest price cialis
buy tadalafil buy tadalafil
generic tadalafil from uk tadalafil without a doctor prescription
cialis without prescription generic cialis tadalafil
628902 541403I truly enjoy seeking through on this internet website , it holds superb content material . 631060
what is tadalafil tadalafil generic where to buy
buy generic cialis online with mastercard tadalafil online with out prescription
cheap cialis pills for sale tadalafil generic
https://cialisusdc.com/ where to buy cialis without prescription
where to buy tadalafil on line generic cialis tadalafil
tadalafil tadalafil price walmart
tadalafil liquid buy tadalis
tadalafil cost in canada buy tadalafil
best price usa tadalafil cialis tadalafil
tadalafil dosage generic cialis online fast shipping
where to buy tadalafil on line where to buy generic cialis online safely
tadalafil drug best price usa tadalafil
tadalafil cost walmart cialis cost
cost of cialis tadalafil without a doctor prescription
cheapest tadalafil cost generic cialis online fast shipping
buy generic cialis online with mastercard tadalafil generic where to buy
where to get tadalafil what is tadalafil
generic cialis tadalafil tadalafil goodrx
tadalafil blood pressure tadalafil goodrx
cialis without a prescription canada generic tadalafil
cost tadalafil generic lowest price cialis
where to buy cialis without prescription cialis tadalafil
https://cialisicp.com/ generic cialis tadalafil
https://nextadalafil.com/ tadalafil blood pressure
tadalafil drug tadalafil price walmart
cialis without a prescription https://cialismat.com/
where to get tadalafil tadalafil online
cost of cialis cialis without a prescription
tadalafil without a doctor prescription https://nextadalafil.com/
tadalafil cialis side effects of tadalafil
buy discount viagra online buy viagra on line
canada generic tadalafil where to order tadalafil tablets
tadalafil 20 india rx tadalafil
stromectol 0.5 mg stromectol tab price
tadalafil liquid tadalafil cost walmart
tadalafil bitcoin thundersplace tadalafil troche (lozenge) where to buy
price of ivermectin ivermectin brand name
cialis at canadian pharmacy tadalafil price walmart
tadalafil generic cialis cost
ivermectin 8 mg ivermectin human
order stromectol online ivermectin uk buy
cost of cialis tadalafil goodrx
ivermectin 3mg tablets ivermectin 8 mg
stromectol price usa ivermectin 2
ivermectin 9 mg ivermectin pill cost
ivermectin 6 ivermectin 4000
purchase ivermectin stromectol
where to buy ivermectin buy liquid ivermectin
buying cheap cialis online fake cialis
stromectol online canada ivermectin lice oral
100mg viagra sildenafil 20 mg cost
buy ivermectin pills where can i buy stromectol
buying cialis without prescription cialis manufacturer coupon 2019
tadalafil over the counter usa vikalis 20mg tadalafil
sildenafil dosage for erectile dysfunction sildenafil classification
cialis price cheap tadalafil
viagra soft tabs generic viagra sildenafil
tadalafil xtenda tadalafil)
viagra online us pharmacy safe place to buy viagra
tadalafil 25mg cheap tadalafil on line
foreign pharmacy online overseas online pharmacy no prescription
optimal rx pharmacy perscription drugs in canada
levitra and premature ejaculation viagra vs cialis vs levitra price
is canadian family pharmacy legitimate harris teeter pharmacy
teva cialis canadian pharmacy no prescription cialis
king canadian pharmacy discount code vardenafil canadian pharmacy
pfizer sildenafil where can u buy viagra
walgreens pharmacy burnt store road meds online
injectable ivermectin for horses drug ivermectin
ivermectin sheep drench tractor supply ivermectin dose dogs
buy viagra 100mg where to buy viagra pharmacy
tadalafil peptide tadalafil 40 mg
levitra 40 mg dose levitra costs
buy viagra online no prescription sildenafil 100mg cost
312980 539028I was suggested this internet website by my cousin. Im not confident whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my dilemma. Youre incredible! Thanks! 369199
buy cialis online australia cialis 20mg cost?
brand levitra levitra online prescription
online pharmacy fungal nail best drugstore makeup
how long before cialis kicks in cialis costco price
british pharmacy online u s a online pharmacy
pharmacy tech degree online canada pharmacy online.com
online cvs pharmacy canadian pharmacies tadalafil
Nexium Starlix
cvs pharmacy online shopping canadian pharmacy 3
canada pharmacy online legit canadian pharmacy for pets
legitimate canadian pharmacy sites how to order prescription drugs from canada
buy provigil 100mg pills order provigil generic
buy provigil 200mg provigil 100mg canada
canada ed drugs canadian drug pharmacy promo code
what Is The Cost Of Cialis?
modafinil 100mg pill buy generic modafinil 200mg
how To Get An Increase The Benefits Of Cialis?
canadian prescription drugs
canadian overnight pharmacy
viagra price
canada pharmacies